The Best Ice Packs for Coolers: Top Selections for 2023

#1 Pick

Arctic Ice Chillin' Brew Series

Runner-up

Fit & Fresh XL Cool Coolers Ice Pack Set of 4

Best Budget

Polar Tech Ice Brix TP12/MS Viscous Cold Pack
#1 Pick
Arctic Ice Chillin' Brew Series
Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series Reusable Ice
Score 9.0 OUT OF 10
Runner-up
Cool Coolers by Fit & Fresh 4 Pack XL Slim Ice Packs
Fit & Fresh XL Cool Coolers Ice Pack Set of 4
Score 9.0 OUT OF 10
Best Budget
Polar Tech TP12 MS Ice Brix Viscous Gel Moisture Safe Refrigerant Cold Pack
Polar Tech Ice Brix TP12/MS Viscous Cold Pack
Score 9.0 OUT OF 10
YETI ICE 2 lb. Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack
YETI ICE 2 lb Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack
Score 9.4 OUT OF 10
Bentgo® Buddies Reusable Ice Packs - Slim Ice Packs for Lunch Boxes
Bentgo Buddies Reusable Ice Packs
Score 9.6 OUT OF 10
Kona XXL Large Cooler Ice Packs
Kona XL Large Cooler Ice Packs
Score 9.2 OUT OF 10
Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs for Cooler - Long-Lasting Cold Freezer Packs
Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs
Score 9.2 OUT OF 10

Nothing befits a picnic or camping trip than properly chilled food and beverages. Hence the crucial importance of a reliable ice pack. From gel ice packs to specialized ice packs that contain gel, we’ll be diving deep into the world of ice packs in 2023. Our top selection includes a range of ice packs fit for every cooler, preference, and pocket. 

Defying the Ice Pack Paradigm: Why Ice Packs Over Regular Ice?

So why are we talking about ice packs and not regular ice cubes? Ice packs have a few tricks up their sleeves. For starters, they are made to last way longer than your regular ice. Plus, there’s no mess to clean up once they melt. On top of that, some of these ice packs like the Arctic Ice Chillin Brew 10Lb Ice Pack, can go down to as low as 28ºF. That’s colder than your regular ice!

The Search for the Best: Comprehensive Reviews

Let’s dig a bit deeper into this frosty world, shall we? To get the best out of your ice packs, there’s more to it than just tossing them into your cooler.

1. Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series Reusable Ice

Score 9.0 OUT OF 10
1 - Arctic Ice Chillin' Brew Series

Let’s kick things off with the big dog – the Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series. This beast is a workhorse, guys. The Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series is a top contender when it comes to the best overall ice pack. Fit for any camping trip, the name says it all. With the Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series, you’re not only chilling your brew but also doing it in style. Reusable, rugged, and super-cool, it ensures your food and drinks stay cold and tasty until the last bit.

Key Features

The Arctic Ice Chillin’ Brew Series is known for its long-lasting cooling effect. – just what you need for those hot summer campouts – or even a regular picnic. Crafted from vegetable oils, it is a natural and eco-friendly option. With a freezing point of 28ºF (-2ºC), it packs a chilly punch. This ice pack is reusable up to 100,000 times, providing excellent value for money. And with its leak-proof design, you get a clean and hassle-free cooling experience. Available in different sizes – including a hefty 10 lb pack and a nifty 1 lb brick – it caters to every cooling need. 

Pros
  • Compact, lightweight, and slim
  • Reusable and eco-friendly
  • Designed to stay cold for longer periods
Cons
  • Requires longer freezing time to reach optimal temperature.
  • Not as flexible as other ice packs, potentially limiting packing options.

2. Fit & Fresh XL Cool Coolers Ice Pack Set of 4

Score 9.4 OUT OF 10
2 - Cool Coolers by Fit & Fresh 4 Pack XL Slim Ice Packs

Fit & Fresh XL Cool Coolers Ice Pack Set of 4 is ideal for folks who need to carry their chiller in a backpack or small carrier. Despite their slim design, these packs can keep their cool for hours, making them efficient little chillers that don’t take up too much space.

Key Features

What makes the Fit & Fresh XL Cool Coolers stand out is their slimline design, measuring just 4.75″ x 2.25″ x 7″. They are designed to fit conveniently into lunch boxes and small coolers. It’s a grand fit for a lunch box, tote, or small cooler. Each pack has BPA-free, non-toxic gel inside that freezes fast and holds it cold. The set of four means you can rotate them out, always having a cold one handy. They are reusable and long-lasting, providing excellent cooling power for extended periods. Despite their slim design, these ice packs are able to maintain low temperatures for a long time, making them an efficient choice for keeping your food and drinks cool and fresh.

Pros
  • Perfectly sized for lunch boxes and small coolers
  • Keeps food and beverages cool for extended periods
  • Reusable and durable, providing excellent value for money
Cons
  • Slightly heavier than other options
  • Won’t fit in oddly shaped coolers

3. Polar Tech Ice Brix TP12/MS Viscous Cold Pack

Score 9.0 OUT OF 10
2 - Cool Coolers by Fit & Fresh 4 Pack XL Slim Ice Packs

Who says you gotta spend a fortune to keep your drinks cold? Not us, that’s for sure. Enter the Polar Tech Ice Brix TP12/MS Viscous Cold Pack. It provides reliable cooling without breaking the bank. Despite its affordable price, it does not compromise on performance, offering efficient cooling that lasts.

Key Features

Polar Tech’s Ice Brix Viscous Cold Pack is a force to be reckoned with. It’s uniquely designed to be both affordable and effective. It is a compact design, making it perfect for tight spaces or smaller coolers. And the best part? It’s reusable. Simply chuck it back in the freezer and it’s ready to go again once it’s frozen solid. Its non-toxic gel maintains a steady temperature to keep items cool for an extended period. Made in the USA, this ice pack is all about delivering high-quality coolness on a budget. 

Pros
  • Highly affordable option 
  • Non-toxic gel ensures safe and efficient cooling 
  • Durable construction for repeated use 
  • Versatile sizes and shapes fit a variety of coolers
Cons
  • The size and slim design, while ideal for lunch bags, might not be suitable for larger coolers
  • Takes 25 minutes to freeze

4. YETI ICE 2 lb Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack

Score 9.6 OUT OF 10
4 - YETI ICE 2 lb. Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack

Let’s talk about the YETI ICE 2 lb Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack. It is one of the largest ice packs on the market, but don’t let that intimidate you. With its outer shell made of BPA-free plastic, this ice pack can keep your cooler colder for an impressive 48 hours. In layman’s terms, that’s a whole lot of cooling power! And with a freezing temperature of 32 degrees, it’ll keep your perishables chilled for an entire weekend getaway.

Key Features

Imagine an ice pack that’s got the power of the largest ice block wrapped in a convenient package. That’s the YETI ICE 2 lb Refreezable Reusable Cooler Ice Pack for you. Its cooling power is unmatched by most other packs on the market. It’s not just the cooling power that’s impressive; its dimensions of 8 x 5 x 1 make it fitting for almost any cooler.

Pros
  • Powerful cooling action for up to 48 hours
  • Freezes at 32 degrees providing optimal chill
  • BPA-free outer shell for safer food storage
  • Perfect for both small and large coolers
Cons
  • May be too large for smaller coolers
  • Heavier than other ice packs

5. Bentgo Buddies Reusable Ice Packs

Score 9.6 OUT OF 10
5 - Bentgo® Buddies Reusable Ice Packs - Slim Ice Packs for Lunch Boxes

Dive into the colorful world of the Bentgo Buddies Reusable Ice Packs. These ice packs are not just kid-friendly but adult-approved too. They come alive with flamboyant designs like pineapples, unicorns, and sharks, doubling the fun while keeping your food chill. Each pack in the set of four is no bigger than your hand, fitting nicely into lunch bags and box sleeves.

Key Features

These fellas were initially made for lunch boxes, but don’t let that fool ya. They are so versatile that you can toss them in lunch bags too, specially made for adults. And talk about color! They light up your cooler with vibrant hues and fun shapes like unicorns, pineapples, and sharks. Ain’t that a sight! They fit snugly in your hand and can be positioned in a lunch box pocket or directly in the cooler. Plus, they don’t shirk on performance – they keep items cool for around 4 hours straight. And in case you’re wondering, the pack size is x 4, measuring about 5 x 4 x inches. Ain’t that something? 

Pros
  • Compact size and lightweight
  • Fun designs can bring joy to kids and adults alike
  • Can keep items fresh for up to 4 hours
  • Eco-friendly 
  • Affordable price for a set of four
Cons
  • May not last as long as full-sized ice packs for coolers
  • Only effective for short periods – not suitable for long trips

6. Kona XL Large Cooler Ice Packs

Score 9.6 OUT OF 10
6 - Kona XXL Large Cooler Ice Packs

The Kona XL Large Cooler Ice Packs are pretty much the heavyweights of the ice pack world. They’re known for their size – a whopping extra-large, aiming to keep your food and drinks chilled for a really long time.

Key Features

These ice packs sport a unique cooling formula that ensures your cooler stays cold for an extended period. And, they are mighty durable, as these packs can handle quite a lot without getting banged up or busted. Their heavy-duty plastic ice exterior is built sturdy and reliable. What’s more, they’re sporting some nifty non-toxic gel inside, so you don’t have to worry about any harmful chemicals messing up your food and drinks. Moreover, they come in a set of two for that extra cooling power.

Pros
  • XL size gives more cooling effect
  • Reusable and eco-friendly
  • Durable and leak-proof
Cons
  • Heavy to carry around
  • Require more space in your cooler

7. Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs

Score 9.2 OUT OF 10
7 - Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs for Cooler - Long-Lasting Cold Freezer Packs

We’ve got here the Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs – these little fellas mean business! Y’know what they say – don’t judge a book by its cover, or in this case, an ice pack by its size.

Key Features

The Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs are packed with features that contribute to their performance. They are made from a non-hazardous, biodegradable material, ensuring the safety of your food and drinks. Don’t worry, these guys won’t leave any water mess in your cooler, ’cause they’re made to be sweat-free – dry outside, cold inside. These packs are also designed with a durable, multi-layer construction that can withstand frequent use. And the best part? They feature a screw cap that allows easy filling and sealing and deliver rapid cooling thanks to their unique formula. The use of a gel rather than water ensures a longer-lasting cooling effect. 

Pros
  • Compact size suitable for many coolers
  • Rapid freezing capability
  • Durable, reusable and sustainable
Cons
  • Heavier than other ice packs
  • Require longer pre-freezing time

Buying Guide: Important Key Factors When Choosing an Ice Pack

If there’s one thing that’s universal, it’s the need for a cold beverage on a hot day. When it comes to choosing the right kind of ice pack for your cooler, a couple of key factors come into play. You have your ice pack sizes, your designs, the ratio of ice packs to cooler sizes, and the ins and outs of cleaning and storing these cold treasures. Let’s dive into the details.

Understanding Ice Pack Sizes

To start off, let’s talk about the size of ice packs. Now, every size has its purpose. You’re not gonna need an ice brick for a six-pack cooler, nor will a pea-sized ice pack cut it for your camping cooler. The bigger the cooler, the beefier the ice pack. 

Dive Into Ice Pack Designs

Next up, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of ice pack designs. Now, you might be thinking, “What’s there to know? They’re just frozen blocks, right?”. These ice packs are more than just frozen water. They’re engineered to stay frozen longer and to withstand the harshest of environments. So when deciding on a design, keep in mind the durability, longevity, leak-proofing, and the materials used. 

The Crucial Role of Ice Pack to Cooler Size Ratio

One thing that often gets overlooked is the ice pack-to-cooler size ratio. You might think it’s about matching the cooler size, but what you really want to pay attention to is the amount of food and beverages you’re trying to keep chilled. For a compact cooler, you’ll want twice the amount of ice packs as the amount of food or drink. 

Instructions on Cleaning and Storing Ice Packs

Alright, last but not least, let’s go over cleaning and storing ice packs. The thought might pop into your head: “Ice packs? Cleaning? They’re in the cooler, what’s there to clean?” Ice packs can get dirty, and dirty ice packs can lead to dirty coolers and nobody wants that. So, to keep your ice packs spick-and-span, give them a good wipe-down with a damp cloth before you put them back in the freezer. As for storage, make sure to keep them upright in your freezer to prevent any possible leaks. 

Commonly Asked Questions about Ice Packs

Positioning the ice pack: Top or bottom of the cooler?

Now, this right here is a million-dollar question. Do you put the ice pack on the top or the bottom of the cooler? Some folks will tell you to slap it right on top because cold air sinks, keeping your food and beverages colder for longer. But then, your outdoorsy types tend to prefer a layered system. They’ll put an ice pack at the bottom, stack the food and beverages in the middle, and top the whole thing off with ice cubes. 

What’s the optimal way of packing a cooler?

You might think the size of your cooler calls the shots on how many ice packs you need. It’s not about how big your cooler is, but how much food and drinks you’ve got inside. Regardless of the cooler’s size, go with twice the amount of ice packs as the amount of food and drink. That way, you’ve got yourself a chilly little haven, perfectly primed to keep your eats and drinks frosty.

What are the advantages of using ice packs over regular ice?

While regular ice is a common choice for cooling cooler bags, ice packs present several advantages. One of the main benefits is the longevity of ice packs. High-quality ice packs like the Arctic Ice Chillin Brew can keep your food and beverages cold for a significantly longer period compared to regular ice. Furthermore, ice packs are reusable, which makes them a more economical and environmentally friendly choice in the long run. They also have a defined freezing point, which helps to maintain a consistent temperature inside the cooler. Lastly, ice packs, unlike regular ice, do not melt into a watery mess, thus keeping your cooler clean and your food and beverages dry.

Summing Up Our Guide to the Best Ice Packs for Coolers: Make Your Coolers the Best They Can Be!

Our extensive guide has led us through the journey of understanding why ice packs, particularly gel-based ice packs, are a superior choice over regular ice. They are designed to maintain cold temperatures for longer periods, keeping your snacks cool and fresh in your cooler. 

Pair one of these ice packs with a robust RTIC cooler, and you’ll be sipping on frosty drinks while everyone else is stuck with lukewarm brews. But remember, not all ice packs are created equal—some gel freezes at a lower temperature. And while “best” might be subjective, we all know what’s “best” for you might not be “best” for me. You gotta weigh in all the factors: size, design, and capacity. And, of course, it’s gotta fit your budget too! 

By now, you must think you’re some ice pack connoisseur, and you’re not wrong! With the right know-how on positioning, the optimal way of packing a cooler, and the secrets behind why ice packs give regular ice a run for its money, you’re more than equipped to make the best choice. 

Leave a Comment